Josh Della Puca had a hat trick for 9-0 Pleasantville, and scored the game-winner with 2:47 remaining.
Carson Cerrito, Dillon Marley, Louis Lustenberger, Andrew Brennan and Jake Scarpoli each had a goal for Irvington, which fell to 3-3.
Oscar Marchi made six saves for Pleasantville, while Josh Schultz had 14 saves for Irvington.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Lewisboro and receive free news updates.